NotRenewingNotRenewing
All Comparisons

NotRenewing vs Sedo: Domain Marketplace Comparison

Overview

Sedo is one of the world's largest domain aftermarket platforms, operating since 2001. With over 18 million domains listed and a global network of buyers and sellers, Sedo is a cornerstone of the domain industry. They offer direct sales, auctions, brokerage services, and domain parking.

NotRenewing is a focused marketplace specifically for domains that owners aren't planning to renew, with a unique fixed $99 pricing model.

Feature Comparison

Market Focus

Sedo: A general-purpose domain aftermarket. Sellers list domains at any price, from $100 to $10 million. Covers the full spectrum of domain transactions including premium names, brandable domains, and portfolio sales.

NotRenewing: Focused exclusively on expiring domains — names that current owners have decided not to renew. This creates a specific, curated marketplace where every listing represents a genuine availability.

Winner: Sedo for breadth. NotRenewing for focus and intent.

Pricing

Sedo: Sellers set their own prices. Listings range from reasonable to wildly optimistic. Negotiation is common and expected. Make-offer transactions can drag on for weeks.

NotRenewing: Every domain is $99. This eliminates negotiation entirely and creates a buyer-friendly experience where decisions are based purely on whether you want the domain, not whether the price is fair.

Winner: NotRenewing for simplicity and buyer experience. Sedo for sellers who want to maximize revenue on premium names.

Fees and Commissions

Sedo:

  • Seller commission: 10-20% depending on sale type
  • Buyer commission: 0-10% depending on sale type
  • Transfer escrow: included
  • Minimum listing: Free for basic, paid for featured placement

    • NotRenewing:

  • Seller fees: Free to list (beta)
  • Buyer cost: $99 flat, no additional commissions
  • Transfer protection: included

    • Winner: NotRenewing for both buyers and sellers on lower-value domains. Sedo's commissions make more sense for high-value transactions.

    Global Reach

    Sedo: Operates in over 20 languages with a global buyer network. If you have a domain that appeals to international buyers, Sedo's reach is unmatched.

    NotRenewing: Primarily English-language marketplace focused on major TLDs (.com, .net, .org, .io, .ai).

    Winner: Sedo for international domains. NotRenewing for English-language TLDs.

    Seller Experience

    Sedo: Listing a domain involves setting a price, choosing a sale type (fixed price, auction, make offer), and optionally paying for featured placement. The platform handles everything, but sellers give up 10-20% in commissions.

    NotRenewing: List for free, verify via DNS, and domains go live. When sold, the seller provides the auth code and gets paid after the buyer confirms transfer. Simple, fast, no commission (during beta).

    Winner: NotRenewing for simplicity and cost. Sedo for established domain professionals who want more control.

    Domain Parking

    Sedo: Offers domain parking that displays ads and generates revenue while your domain is listed for sale. This can offset holding costs for large portfolios.

    NotRenewing: No parking service. Since the focus is on expiring domains (short-term listings), parking isn't necessary.

    Winner: Sedo. Parking is valuable for portfolio holders.

    Who Should Use Each?

    Choose Sedo if:

  • You're selling premium domains worth $500+
  • You want international buyer exposure
  • You need domain parking revenue
  • You're a professional domainer with a large portfolio
  • You want full control over pricing

    • Choose NotRenewing if:

  • You're selling domains you're not renewing (regardless of value)
  • You want to sell quickly without negotiation
  • You're buying domains and want predictable $99 pricing
  • You prefer simplicity over features
  • You don't want to pay commissions

    • The Bottom Line

    Sedo is the premium, full-featured domain marketplace for the domain industry. NotRenewing is the simple, fixed-price marketplace for expiring domains. If you're selling a $10,000 domain, Sedo makes sense despite the commissions. If you're selling or buying domains in the $50-$500 value range, NotRenewing's $99 fixed price and zero-commission model is hard to beat.

    Many domain professionals use both: Sedo for their premium inventory, and NotRenewing for domains they're simply not renewing.

    Ready to try NotRenewing?

    Browse expiring domains at a fixed $99 price. No auctions, no negotiation, no commissions.

    Browse DomainsList Your Domains

    Other Comparisons

    vs GoDaddy Auctionsvs NameJet